: : Home    : : Awards Nite    : : The Background    : : Winners    : : Evaluation Process    : : Contact Us    
 
 
  ..: Evaluation Process  
 


Jury
- 3rd Bry-Air Awards


Prof. R.S. Agarwal, Chairman, Jury Panel
Prof. Mechnical Engineering Department
Indian Insititute of Technology, Delhi
       
Prof. S.S. Murthy
Prof. Department of Mechnical Engg.
Indian Institute of Technology, Madras
Dr. Ajay Mathur
Director General
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Mr. Pankaj Dharkar
President, ISHRAE-HQ
Pankaj Dharkar & Associates
Mr. Sunil Gupta
President - ASHRAE India Chapter
Gupta Consultants & Associates

The jury adopted a matrix approach for evaluation of the nominations.

The Jury members reviewed every nomination and rated them independently first and then discussed details of each to validate their evaluation. The whole process was transparent and decisions unanimous.

 
 
2
  Criteria for Student Category : Innovative Project
 
 
»

Originality/Innovation

» Energy Saving
» Environment Friendly
 
 
2
  Criteria for Evaluation for Product Design :
 
 
»

Ease of Manufacturing & Maintenance

» Innovation
» Energy Saving
» Environment Friendly
» Relevance to India and Potential for Replicability
 
Prerequisite for "Excellence in Product Design": Product has to be commercialized
 
2
  Criteria for Systems Design :
 
 
»

Originality of Idea & Uniqueness

» Energy Saving
» Environment Friendly
» Cost Effectiveness
»

Relevance to India and Potential for Replicability

 
Prerequisite for "Excellence in System Design": Commissioned and Tested
2
1 1 1
     
 

Jury Panel - 2nd Bry-Air Awards

» Dr. S. Devotta, Chairman, Jury Panel
Director
NEERI
» Prof. R.S. Agarwal
Emeritus Chair Professor (Mech. Engg.)
IIT, Delhi
» Mr. Hiru M. Jhangiani
Editor
Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Journal
» Mr. Ramesh Paranjey
Fellow ASHRAE, USA
»

Mr. Richie Mittal
President, ASHRAE India Chapter
Roots Air Systems Pvt. Ltd.

»

Mr. V. Krishnan
President, ASHRAE Western Indian Chapter
Dynacraft Air Controls

» Mr. Satish Iyengar
President, ISHRAE HQ
Service Consultant

The jury adopted a matrix approach for evaluation of the nominations. A matrix aproach was adopted by the jury to is adopted.

The Jury members reviewed every nomination and rated them independently first and then discussed details of each to validate their evaluation. The whole process was transparent and decisions unanimous.

 
 
Prerequisite for "Excellence in Product Design": Product has to be commercialized

 
 
Criteria for Further Evaluation
» Ease of Manufacturing & Maintenance
» Innovation
» Energy Saving
» Environment Friendly
» Benefit to Society
 
2
  Prerequisite for "Excellence in System Design": Commissioned and Tested
 
 
Criteria
» Originality of Idea & Uniqueness
» Energy Saving
» Environment Friendly
» Cost Effectiveness
»

Benefit to Society

 
     
1 1 1
     
 

Jury Panel - 1st Bry-Air Awards

» Dr. Rajeshwar Malhotra, Chairman, Jury Panel
Managing Director
Spirotech Heat Exchanger Pvt. Ltd.
» Dr. S. Devotta
Director
NEERI
» Mr. S.S. Murthy
Professor Mechnical Engineering
IIT
» Ms. Mili Majumdar
Fellow & Area Convenor
TERI
» Mr. Kapil Mehrotra
President, ASHRAE India Chapter
» Mr. G. Anand Kumar
President, ISHRAE Headquarters


The jury adopted a matrix approach for evaluation of the nominations. A matrix aproach was adopted by the jury to is adopted.

The Jury members reviewed every nomination and rated them independently first and then discussed details of each to validate their evaluation. The whole process was transparent and decisions unanimous.

 
  Prerequisite for "Excellence in Product Design": Product has to be commercialized
 
 
Criteria for Further Evaluation
» Capable for being replicated i.e. Manufacturing Base
» Market reach and share in Indian market
» Exports
» Competition
» Innovatation
» Patents
» Energy saving
» Environment friendly
 

  Prerequisite for "Excellence in System Design": Commissioned and Tested
 
 
Criteria
» Trend setting
» Uniqueness
» Energy Saving
» Environment Friendly
»

Relevent to indian conditions
*  Temp Design Suitable to Indian Company
*  Power Break Down
*  Shortage of Water
*  Quality of Water

» Completeness of system
 
     
 
Copyright © 2008 Bry-Air (Asia) Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved.
Best viewed in screen resolution 800X600